Moana (2026)

If you want to know how far I’ll go for the people who take the time to read what I have to say, I watched live-action Moana, which, for some completely absurd reason, released 10 years after the animated version. Just check. This, of course, was mocked by critics and influencers online. There was a slight debate from some who felt everybody was being a bit too harsh, and Disney mostly reminded the naysayers that it would do well on streaming. I’m here to talk about it, so you’re welcome.

First, to tackle the idea of should this movie exist, the answer is no. It should not. Disney once lived on imagination. They literally call their creative team Imagineers. Now they just remake their own things or keep propagating the world with sequels, expanding franchises. On the rare occasion we actually get an original story, it seems like a blessing, but also a curse, because now the original thing has to live up to the hype of all of these major franchises. It’s much easier to market a new Toy Story movie than it is to market an animated feature about, well, basically Avatar, except on Earth and trying to save woodland creatures in their biome. Which was also kind of the plot of FernGully, and yes, James Cameron clearly had a lot of heavy and obvious influences when he made Avatar. And then when Pixar made Hoppers, they had openly addressed how it wasn’t Avatar, but let’s face it, it’s Avatar. Which is FernGully, or Pocahontas, or whichever other story you saw inspiration pulled from. The fact is that Hoppers is technically an original work, and it’s harder to sell than a Toy Story movie. So on the live-action front, it makes sense to just keep finding ways to turn their animated features into live-action films. And with Moana, they have the opportunity of using a movie star in Dwayne Johnson, and they moved quickly enough that they could actually put him in the same role he voiced for the animated feature. Again, you’re welcome.

But to the comment that this will do well on streaming, I would counter that with, really, it will? Are you sure? I mean, I’m sure people will check it out because they’re already subscribed, and for a one-time watch, it’s sort of a curiosity. But why on earth would you continue to watch the lesser version of something when you can watch the original that is still better? That’s the one thing I haven’t understood about these attempts to adapt a classic Disney cartoon. If you’re not going to do anything different with it, and take a character in a new direction, all you’re doing is replicating what already worked before. And anytime somebody sits down and wants to watch a movie, they have choices on Disney+ between the original animated Moana that they fell in love with, or this bizarre facsimile that came about 10 years later, which didn’t really rewrite the songbook, add major new characters, or change much of the dialogue. It’s pretty much a beat-by-beat remake, not a fully shot-for-shot remake, but it certainly strives to hit all of the same notes at the same times as the original feature. They’ve evolved some of the humor, changed some of the jokes, but it’s basically the film you’ve already seen and loved before, with the same songs you’ve been singing for 10 years.

And I know that this seems like a rain-on-the-parade type review, but it’s actually not entirely, because if I was in the middle of a conversation right now with a room full of critics, this is where I would say, so why is it rotten? Why would you put this as a not recommend if you are recommending Moana, the 2016 version? I can understand a critic who didn’t like the original Moana not feeling like the live-action version did anything new to switch what was a not recommend to recommend. But for me, especially as somebody who loved Moana, this is still the same story. It’s the same girl. She’s going on the same journey. She’s literally meeting the same exact guy that she met in the 1st film, played by the same exact actor. They have the same exact goal, and they sing the same songs. This is that movie. They have replicated it. And because it is so close to the original source material, unabashedly so, it makes it really hard for me, even as I am fully aware that the existence of this is completely and totally unnecessary, to call it a bad film. That does not necessarily mean that the film in and of itself is a bad film. It just means it’s an unnecessary film, but still watchable. Because the story of Moana is watchable. Because it’s fun to watch this Disney princess go out on her adventure and use her wayfinding ways to try to find the heart of Te Fiti and return it, while also trying to convince Maui to make better life choices, be the hero demigod he thinks he is, and save the day.

Yes, we have changed the actress who plays Moana, naturally, because Auliʻi Cravalho, who voiced Moana in the 2016 version, is now 10 years older, so she would have a bit harder time playing Moana at the age she’s supposed to be. This time, Catherine Lagaʻaia plays Moana. Much like the Lilo & Stitch live-action adaptation brought us a bright new talent as Lilo, children grow up. It means they can’t repeat the role they played. If Pixar were to greenlight a live-action Toy Story, and don’t think we haven’t thought about that, the actor playing Andy is not going to return as Andy, because he’s probably in his 40s.

I don’t have too many specific complaints. I thought for being the cinematic equivalent of a replicant, Moana 2026 did a fine job of capturing the vibes of the 1st film. Sure, it seems redundant if you are already a fan of the 1st film. But if you’re being honest with yourself, it is still the same film. It has the same themes, characters, story, structure, music. Everything that you fell in love with is still captured here, which made the ride for me very similar to what I saw the 1st time through. The audio description track here is really pretty good. I think it struggled a little bit in places with how to bring audio description in at times when that conflicts with the music. But I can’t confirm or deny how some of the visuals landed. Yes, Dwayne Johnson is still charming as Maui, even if, from what I understand, his wig looks terrible. Even though it is a copy, that doesn’t necessarily mean it would warrant the same score. No, the fact that this still has a decent audio description track, a solid cast, and is nearly identical to a film I already love makes it really hard for me to come up with a reason to throw it in as a rotten, not recommend.

I don’t think there’s much point to the film. But for people who love Moana, maybe they need a live-action version. Maybe they want to watch Moana when grandpa is over, but he doesn’t watch cartoons. So this gives them the opportunity to watch the same thing, but live-action. Ultimately, though, I think it just serves very little purpose. So while I maintain that the love for the 1st one keeps me from going rotten on this unnecessary film, sure, it’ll play well on Disney+ for that one-time viewing. But my prediction is that, ultimately, as time passes, more people will go back to watching the animated version than watching the inferior live-action version. Either way, though, the story of Moana is classic and deserves to be watched in either format.

Fresh: 6.5/10

Leave a Reply