So that’s why the lady is a tramp. I didn’t fully understand it until now, but now I do, courtesy of Lady, the feature directorial debut of Samuel Abrahams, which premiered at the 2025 BFI London Film Festival and is now rolling out to audiences. While the presentation I received did not include audio description, I have to say this is still one of my favorite films of the year. What a strange, weird little movie. I loved every minute of it. It has these Grey Gardens vibes that I just couldn’t get past, where you have this upper-class socialite, Lady Isabella, played by Siân Clifford, this extension of British peerage with a title and a massive historic manor, who bedazzles an upstart documentarian named Sam, played by Laurie Kynaston, into putting the focus solely on her.
There are so many layers to this onion to peel back, some of them more obvious than others. Even without audio description, the film vocalizes the fact that, for whatever reason, Lady Isabella is literally going invisible. She needs to be seen, and if she cannot be seen, she actually starts to disappear. Her fear of slipping into obscurity physically manifests into becoming the very thing she fears: invisible. She’s so odd and eccentric that Siân Clifford’s performance here is nothing short of brilliant. It’s such a wild and wacky character, something Yorgos Lanthimos might have centered one of his films around. She’s incredibly proud of everything she’s achieved, everything she is, and everything she believes she has accomplished, even as Sam starts realizing, bit by bit, the truth behind her fables. He’s also able to manipulate her to some extent by dangling a Netflix-shaped carrot in front of her, suggesting that perhaps her life won’t be deemed irrelevant or forgotten because Netflix might actually be interested in her story.
It’s so much fun watching these characters engage in this increasingly irreverent discourse throughout the film, becoming this bizarre odd couple. Clifford’s Lady Isabella reminded me of so many other performances built around women whose lives have led them to believe that they are, in some regard, exceptional because of their status or position, someone like Florence Foster Jenkins, where the idea that they could be anything but extraordinary has simply never entered their minds. But I think what’s truly interesting here is taking something that could have remained subtext and actually manifesting it physically. Lady Isabella isn’t simply afraid that nobody wants to watch her anymore. She actually begins to fade away, as though a lack of attention could erase her from existence.
On top of that, this is Samuel Abrahams’ first feature, which kind of blows my mind because it’s so strong and confident. It reminds me a little bit of another film out of the UK that also emerged this year, The Incomer, which was similarly bold, bizarre and darkly hilarious. Lady has so many of those same shades, but manipulates them differently. There’s something wonderfully pointed about the way it pays homage to every kept woman who has ever acquired a hobby and decided that hobby must somehow be shared with the world because surely it proves how extraordinarily unique she is.
But hidden underneath Lady and all of its absurdity about the fear of fading relevance is an evolving generational relationship between Lady Isabella and Sam that starts to manifest almost as a conflicted mother-son relationship, despite the fact that these two aren’t related. There is a reason for that, and if you stick with the film long enough, it pays off in spades. That’s part of what keeps Lady from simply being a feature-length joke about an eccentric aristocrat. There’s actual tenderness buried underneath all this lunacy, and the movie gradually allows you to understand why these two people might need each other in ways neither of them fully understands at first.
Lady hasn’t even remotely registered on anyone’s radar for the Oscars, and I kind of get it. It feels like a small movie, and small movies require big studios to push them forward for Oscar campaigns. When you have studios willing to spend $20 million just campaigning to get a Best Picture trophy, and you’re simply happy to be getting theatrical distribution instead of winding up dumped onto some PVOD platform, it becomes a beggars-can’t-be-choosers situation. Still, I’d love to see Siân Clifford recognized somewhere along the way for her work in Lady, because this is one of the most voracious attempts at dominating a film that I’ve seen this year. She commands the entire movie like the conductor of an orchestra, but she does it with such flair that everyone in the concert hall can’t help watching the conductor instead of the orchestra. You’re getting a beautifully conducted piece, but you’re also getting the entertainment value of watching a master at work.
Lady feels like the kind of movie Emma Stone could make ten years from now with a little more age under her belt. She’s still a little too young to pull off everything this character asks of an actress, but considering everything Stone has given us through her collaborations with Yorgos Lanthimos, I could absolutely imagine that if this script had been kicked around for another decade and landed in front of her at exactly the right moment, people would immediately start talking about another Oscar nomination. Unfortunately, Lady doesn’t star Emma Stone. It stars Siân Clifford, which means the performance requires people to actually discover it instead of arriving prepackaged with awards attention.
I don’t know how other critics will appreciate or not appreciate this film, but I thought it was properly bonkers in all the best ways. I truly adored Lady and everything it has to say about not simply the desire to be seen, but the need to be seen, and how easily that need can be manipulated when someone realizes just how desperately you crave the spotlight. It’s strange, funny, sad, surreal and unexpectedly touching, with Siân Clifford giving the kind of fearless performance that deserves far more attention than it is currently getting. Please check out Lady before she vanishes.
Fresh: 8.8/10