Kicking off the Small Screen Diaries for the day, I decided to do something a little different and pick a streaming service and focus on just shows from that lone streaming service. So, along with your spoiler warning, here is a look at my Paramount+ active lineup. I did start 2 new shows in addition to trying to catch up on some old ones. I didn’t get around to all of the shows technically on my watch list from Paramount+, like Lioness and Eternally Yours. Nor did I have a new episode of Dexter: Resurrection to watch. So it’s not a comprehensive list, but it’s a block of shows. And here are their rankings.
In first place, I’ll hand it to Ghosts, season 5, episode 20, with audio description by the Media Access Group. This episode had Sam pitching Polar Opposites, her Christmas romantic comedy, to someone who actually had the opportunity to take the script and do something with it, as she happens to be staying at the bed and breakfast. The end of the episode hints that their little place may be used for an upcoming reality show, which could feed into season 6. There’s also a lot going on with the ghosts that is kind of funny, especially between Thor and the rest, because Thor wants to feel more important as the first gentleman now that Flower is the ghost representative. I thought it was clever and funny and everything Ghosts was supposed to be. So it floats to the top.
In second place, Tracker, season 4, episode 1, with audio description by the Media Access Group. What once was CBS’s number one show has fallen to number 2, as Marshals has finally caught on to the point where everybody assumed it would, being a spinoff of Yellowstone. But Tracker is still doing remarkably well for a show that’s not attached to a franchise, like NCIS. And it’s largely because it has a rhythm to it that it doesn’t break. The season premiere starts off kind of safely, not trying to dive into some deep conspiracy theory like the season 3 premiere did. And it actually played out kind of nicely. There are 2 kids, and their dad goes out after getting a text message and never comes home. The older son finds information about Colter on a subreddit and hires him to find their dad. And he can’t alert the authorities because he’s afraid of him and his little brother being put into child protective services. So Colter’s kind of racing against the clock. Tracker always has solid audio description, and I liked the episode. So it floats up to the top.
Third place goes to MobLand, season 1, episode 10, with audio description. I have to admire Helen Mirren’s performance here. She seems to really enjoy being a villain in this, and she gives it her all. While Tom Hardy is really the star, and if push came to shove and I had to choose which actor to follow in order to push MobLand forward, the show doesn’t work without Tom Hardy. I know that was a little bit of a possible issue with the future of the series, as he is difficult to work with. But while Helen Mirren and Pierce Brosnan are legends, the show actually needs Tom Hardy. But Helen Mirren is giving a delicious performance here, as she usually does. Speaking of, if you haven’t gotten a chance, if it dropped with audio description anywhere, she is also really excellent in A Talent for Murder, playing another unlikable character. I did feel like, as I have with some other scenes that MobLand has had, where I didn’t get all the audio description. For lack of a better definition, so I don’t totally spoil the scene, there’s a hugging sequence here, and there were characters present in the room that I felt like I didn’t know were present in the room until all of a sudden they were. Also, there’s quite a bit of carnage at the end, with some characters getting killed off and not getting to move on to the second season. And I felt like in the wrap-up part of the episode at the end, we could have had a little bit more description of these deaths instead of just mentioning bodies. I’m sure not everybody had a clean death.
Fourth place goes to Golden Axe, season 1, episode 7, with audio description. I love this show. I think it’s funny, and I hope Paramount continues with it. I have no idea if they will or not. I don’t know what the audience looks like for this. But if Paramount is interested in expanding adult animation, I think Golden Axe is an excellent find for them. And especially with audiences looking for something like The Legend of Vox Machina, which is heading into its final season, there might be a place for Golden Axe moving forward on Paramount+ if they allow it. It has nice audio description and a great voice cast.
Fifth place goes to Avatar: Seven Havens, season 1, episode 4, with audio description by International Digital Centre. And this continuation of the franchise is shaping out the future of the secret society and the twin Avatar line pretty well. I don’t know how fans of the original series feel about this iteration, if it’s doing it for them or not. I think I’ve mentioned before that I came into Avatar late because I had friends who kept thrusting it upon me. And even though this is meant largely for kids, it has enough of an adventure element to it that it’s not the most unwatchable show for adults.
And in the bottom spot goes to The Varnell Hill Show, season 1, episode 1, with audio description. I did have a lot of weird issues with this. First of all, the cuts that they have, where we cut to commercial, were unreasonably harsh for some reason. It felt like the episode was poorly edited together and then put on Paramount+, like nobody had really given it a thought of what would this be like if it moved continuously through? The weird thing is that Ghosts and Tracker actually air with commercials on CBS. But The Varnell Hill Show, as far as I know, is only available streaming. I guess the only way that you could get commercials is if you were paying for the lower-tier plan. So I don’t know why this feels so choppy. It’s not that there isn’t talent in the show, and I feel bad for ranking the show with the Black cast at the bottom, but I know it’s a spinoff of Martin, with Tommy Davidson getting an opportunity to lead a show. I didn’t think I would be saying that in 2026, that Tommy Davidson was actually leading a series. But here he is. And much like my problem with A Different World, I just think these shows rely too heavily on people having seen something that is 30-plus years old. So I’m not really sure who the audience for this is. Is it purely nostalgia bait for people who are my generation on up, who remember Martin? Or is this for a younger audience? Because I don’t think it does anything to pull them in. It’s a weird pilot. It doesn’t do much to explain how it came to be. I think it really, even more than the A Different World revival, expects you to know what the hell’s going on right off the bat. And doesn’t do a whole lot of explaining or setting up of the characters and the premise, or even who Varnell Hill is. There’s just too much presumption with some of these shows that are not completely rebooting and erasing the original show, but actually taking elements from the original show. There’s too much of an expectation that people are binge-watching older sitcoms at the right time to warrant this. It doesn’t do enough to stand on its own, like The Paper does, where it feels like it’s inspired by the thing that came before it instead of you needing to absolutely have seen The Office. The Paper works regardless. And then you also have shows that are full resets, and we’ve been having those for years. I know they’re doing another one coming up on NBC this spring based on the old James Garner show. And I wouldn’t expect anybody to go back and watch that show, so I hope the pilot is a hard reset and not expecting people to have seen something that’s older than I am. The audio description was fine. I don’t have any problems with that. But not a great pilot. There’s talent in this show, though. There are a bunch of funny actors and actresses who just need space and a better premise to shine. It’s possible they might make something out of this.
So ranking the audio description, I think I would put Tracker on top and MobLand on the bottom. I felt like Tracker gave me everything, and sometimes I felt like MobLand, for some reason, avoids giving me everything, and I don’t know why. And I’ve felt that for a couple episodes.