*Spoiler Warning*
I think we can all agree that we love Stanley Tucci. I don’t know that this is up for debate. I think that’s why people keep sending him to wander around Italy and filming him, because he is an inherently likable person with a calm demeanor and a sense of warmth about him. I’ve never really understood the desire to turn him into a villain, why he has so many villainous roles on his resume, or why his only Oscar nomination is for playing a really nasty human being in The Lovely Bones. He should be nominated for something that matches why we know and love him. Sort of like Tom Hanks being an everyman. If all of his nominations were for playing villains, it just wouldn’t feel like we understood his vibe very well. But Amazon has swooped in and decided that because Stanley Tucci plays the man behind the organization in Citadel, he must be perfect for a film like Masterplan, where he plays a career thief named Roger, who recruits two very specific thieves, Jay (Victor Belmondo) and Chiara (Simona Tabasco), to pull a job, only to reveal to them that the job was never real, and it was just a hoax to lure them there because he is, in your best Darth Vader voice, their father.
Naturally, these two have wild reactions to this. Of course, they don’t. Chiara is an orphan and has no parents to refer to, but Jay does have a mother, so he calls his mom and questions her about this revelation. She validates the fact that Stanley Tucci’s art thief is, in fact, his father, and that she lied to him all those years. My God, woman. What have you done? So, Roger has a plan. You might call it a master plan. You could also call it an en suite plan, or depending on how you view Stanley Tucci, a mistress plan. But it is a plan to steal the Mona Lisa, because of course it is. Audiences are very basic, and the minute you try to deviate away from one of the paintings they’re familiar with, good luck with that. There’s only ever really a handful of paintings or art pieces that people are trying to steal in movies, because even if something was created by a famous artist, if it isn’t one of those instantly recognizable pieces, they’re not going to put it in a movie. Same thing with opera arias. Anytime you hear an opera aria in a film, it’s always one of the most basic, oversung, overdone ones, like Nessun Dorma or O Mio Babbino Caro. It’s never a deep cut.
So, Roger works with Jay and Chiara on this master plan to steal the Mona Lisa, and because I don’t hate you, I will go ahead and tell you that, in a move that did not shock me at all, he turns out not to be their father and was totally using them to steal the Mona Lisa. So now they have to figure out what to do next, as they are the ones who took all the risks while Stanley Tucci absconds with the reward. How will this movie end? Will you care? That is the big question. I thought Masterplan was bravely dull in the most uncompelling of ways. A film designed to offend no one, appeal to everyone, and have absolutely nothing specific or memorable about it to stand out from the crowd. Masterplan is the kind of film that could benefit from a cable run where you take a nap, wake up, and there’s something playing that looks vaguely familiar to whatever you were watching before. So you just sort of keep watching because you think you’ve seen this before. It’s familiar to you, but then you don’t recognize these people. Who are they? Who are these people? What happened to the movie I was watching before I fell asleep? Did I miss something? Does it matter?
The actors chosen for Jay and Chiara are not ones that I’m instantly familiar with, so Stanley Tucci is driving this piece pretty hard. Considering he’s not the one doing all the heavy action sequences, this very much feels like Citadel, which, while not a perfect show, is still better than this. Director Thomas Vincent has assembled a heist movie that feels like it was constructed out of spare parts from other, better heist movies, without ever finding a reason for this particular one to exist. Masterplan is a waste of Stanley Tucci’s time. It’s a waste of your time. And the only redeeming quality it has is the fact that it has audio description. It’s not that Stanley Tucci is bad here. It’s that the role is bad, and there’s nothing he can do with it. Roger isn’t presented as nefarious enough, or written well enough, to feel like some great criminal mastermind. There’s no clever back-and-forth repartee that puts him in some sort of top echelon of cinematic villains, where you’re never really sure where his loyalties lie. Something like having to work with Hannibal Lecter, where he’s sitting in a glass cell and you need his assistance, but you also know that trusting him could be the worst decision of your life. Instead, Roger is just sort of there, moving the plot along, with the film seemingly convinced that every twist is more surprising than it actually is. There’s also an attempt at unearned warmth by the end of the film that I did not appreciate. You can’t just spend an entire movie manipulating characters and audiences and then expect a little sentimentality to suddenly make everything feel meaningful. You have to earn that emotional payoff, and Masterplan doesn’t.
Sometimes reviews are easy because the film is amazing, and I spend most of my time just praising how much I loved it. Other times, the movie is terrible, and it’s easy to come in and complain about all the things that are wrong with it. I have the most problems with films that are sort of in the middle, feeling closer to a coin toss. Masterplan is actually far from a coin toss. It’s closer to being one of the more obviously bad films of the year, although surprisingly, because I’m now over 300 titles into 2026, this doesn’t even broach my ten worst films of the year. It’s going to get away scot-free with just a decidedly low grade and a hard do-not-watch recommendation from me, along with a sincere apology to Stanley Tucci, because he’s adorable and deserves so much more than this film could ever give him. I loved him in Conclave, and given the fact that he did at least get some awards buzz for his performance in that film, even though it didn’t materialize into an Oscar nomination, you would think the world would have signaled that he could do more of that type of thing. Give this man something worthy of his talents. Give him a character with some depth, some complexity, something that allows him to remind us why we love him in the first place. But alas, he has been given Masterplan, a film that is masterful in nothing except idiocy.
Rotten: 3.2/10