Tyler Perry’s Doing Life

Tyler Perry’s back. I feel like we hear that all the time. I feel like he’s trying to set some sort of world record for how many films he can direct within his lifetime. He’s getting close to 40 films now, and probably next year he’ll hit 40, which is an astounding amount for someone who didn’t start directing features until after September 11th. From Diary of a Mad Black Woman to now, Tyler Perry has amassed a bizarre filmography containing some of the worst films I’ve ever seen, mixed in with promising content and a few underrated gems. Mostly, I think he’s a better actor when he’s not directing himself, notably in performances like Gone Girl and Vice. When he does direct himself, he often just throws on a dress and runs around like a buffoon. His shtick can often bury a better plot with deeper subtext and meaning. Diary of a Mad Black Woman is essentially about a woman escaping an abusive relationship, finding herself again, and falling for someone she actually deserves. For some reason, that movie also has Tyler Perry cross-dressing as Madea, which has absolutely nothing to do with what the movie is really about. Yet somehow, this worked for him on stage, and because Diary of a Mad Black Woman was such a big hit, he took that as a thumbs-up to continue repeating this over and over and over again.

With Tyler Perry’s Doing Life, he has shifted a little more into a feel-good Lifetime or Hallmark-style movie, and it works because it isn’t overly ambitious. It also doesn’t break too far from Tyler Perry’s style. Some of his recent films have felt a little more R-rated than necessary, with over-the-top antics and tawdry sex scenes that Perry sometimes seems uncomfortable directing. Doing Life is mostly a redemption story, taking a paroled inmate with the disastrously stupid name Carousel, played by Jay Reeves, and pairing him with Anika, played by Naomi Baker, a former prison guard who is pregnant and whose baby daddy is nowhere to be found. These two already have a history because, during a prison riot, Carousel protected Anika from the other inmates and potentially saved her life. That act likely helped him eventually get parole, and now, outside of prison, the two reconnect under very different circumstances.

Carousel owns up to his mistakes in the past, although Tyler Perry also gives him easily forgivable trespasses. He was a minor who was tried as an adult, fell in with the wrong crew, didn’t have his father around, lost his mother when he was young, and didn’t listen to his grandmother. Wrong crew, wrong place, wrong time, and he’s grown considerably since then. Somehow, he has also become a legal mastermind while incarcerated, but we’ll get to that. Unfortunately for him, Anika’s family believes he is absolutely the wrong guy for her, even if she increasingly believes he might be the right guy. Her sisters, Trina, played by Karen Obilom, and Lisa, played by Jasmine Sargent, are particularly skeptical of the relationship. So Carousel spends much of the movie essentially pleading his case, proving that he can show up for Anika and that he isn’t some stereotypical rage-machine ex-con. He’s capable of the same human emotions as everyone else: gentleness, kindness, understanding, empathy, and love.

And to be honest, Tyler Perry makes this work. This is one of his better films. It’s not an amazing film, but in terms of streaming titles, what this movie is trying to do, what it asks of the audience, and what that audience should reasonably expect from it, I think it passes those tests. Unless you were expecting some massive, big-budget theatrical event, which would be insane because none of these people are instantly recognizable stars, I don’t think you should be disappointed. If you’re somebody who enjoys Tyler Perry movies and just wants him to act normal and tell a good story, he has basically done that here. The writing is stronger, the story is safe, and the acting is fine. Everything rises just enough above the bar to make this worth the venture if you enjoy Tyler Perry when he makes something worth watching.

Some people will never enjoy anything Tyler Perry makes, but even though I have endless amounts of fun mocking him, I don’t want to be someone who automatically rates everything he does as rotten. That’s not really productive either. It is possible for him to find meaning within his films, to create characters who impact people, and to reach audiences through his stories. He is capable of that. The problem often becomes that he’s doing way too much, juggling too much, and directing too many films. Therein lies the problem. When he slows down enough to focus on a relatively simple story and doesn’t bury it underneath all of his usual excesses, there’s something there. By a fairly slim margin, Doing Life ends up going fresh for me.

If there’s a standout in the cast, it would have to be Tamberla Perry as Anika’s mother, Cathy. She is clearly more than disappointed that Carousel is hanging around, but she’s also struggling with her own health, and the scenes between Cathy and Carousel, when he becomes her caregiver while Anika isn’t around, are some of the better scenes in the movie. The two have to work through their issues despite very clearly not seeing eye to eye, and Cathy is more than happy to refer to him as “convict” instead of Carousel. There’s something surprisingly effective about watching their relationship gradually evolve because Carousel can’t just tell her that he has changed. He has to demonstrate it through how he treats her.

The film gets a little weaker when it tries to loop in the surprise plot involving Anika’s family, and it perhaps overplays Carousel’s legal prowess. At times, the movie treats him like he’s some sort of generational legal mind, despite the fact that he was convicted while he was still in high school and presumably learned most of what he knows through whatever resources he could access while incarcerated. That stretches credibility and feels a little overextended. But those flaws never completely derail the movie or the central relationship. Jay Reeves does a good job of making Carousel feel like an actual person rather than simply Tyler Perry’s idea of what a redeemed ex-con is supposed to look like, and Naomi Baker brings enough warmth to Anika that their relationship works even when Perry’s writing starts pushing things a little too hard.

I also really enjoyed the audio description, which was done by International Digital Center, written by Kyle East and narrated by SRI Gordon. SRI has done quite a bit of Tyler Perry’s work before, not all of it, but enough that she seems to understand the right temperament to bring to one of his films. She complements his work in a lovely manner here, matching the vibe of the movie without pushing too hard in either direction.

Just like his last film, Tyler Perry’s Why Did I Get Married Again?, I was oddly surprised that I actually enjoyed this. Perry has made some truly utter disasters over the last few years. Films like Duplicity and Madea’s Destination Wedding are just god-awful movies. Doing Life is not that. I think there’s an audience for this, and I’m more than happy to recommend it. Tyler Perry’s Doing Life is Tyler Perry doing well and doing what he’s best at: telling a story with heart, relatable characters, and not setting the bar unnecessarily high for himself. And the best part of all? There’s no Madea.

Fresh: 6.5/10

Leave a Reply