I did not know that Steve Buscemi used to be a firefighter. I found that out after noticing he was an executive producer on this documentary about first responders. Pretty crazy, huh? I’ve always been interested in those career transitions. Some kids grow up knowing they want to be an actor, and that’s all they ever do, and they transition straight into it. Others come from an interesting background. And for Buscemi, it was his life as a first responder, which is why he’s lending his credibility to this documentary about first responders all over the country who show up to save lives on a daily basis. Regardless of the severity, regardless of the safety, regardless of the incident in question, first responders, EMTs, firefighters, all rush in to save lives. But what is it really like to be one of these first responders? That is what Into the Unknown is looking to explore, breaking apart the idea that we have around this entire profession.
It doesn’t really directly address whether or not it feels like it has to do this in response to the myriad of shows that feature first responders, as if their portrayal of them is so far off that a documentary crew felt like they had to come in and follow various first responders all over the country in order to document their lives and their various thoughts and stories. It isn’t necessarily a recruitment video either. It doesn’t have that kind of sheen that suggests, come and follow in my footsteps. If anything, it reminds us that those seemingly crazy storylines that we see on shows like Third Watch or Chicago Fire are actually true sometimes. A paramedic will roll up to a dangerous situation and end up putting their own life at risk when a gang member holds them at gunpoint, expecting them to save their friend’s life. It seems like it’s too hot for TV, but apparently these are real things that happen to real people who are just doing their job.
So you would think that this life, this calling, has an incredibly high turnover rate. Not necessarily. People get into this line of work and have to pass hours upon hours of training before they can get out into the field. They’re qualified to provide a range of on-the-spot medical care, and while they won’t be doing brain surgery in the back of an ambulance, they will be trying to keep you alive by any means necessary through their training, whether you require intubation or blood. They can shock you back to life in certain circumstances and keep you going just long enough until you get to the hospital. Everything they do is essentially a race against time. Of course, everything that I’m saying is mostly what people already know about first responders. So in terms of pulling back the curtain, what exactly did this documentary do to go deeper, to go further, to go into the unknown? Sadly, not much.
There are a couple of mentions of stories where the paramedics themselves were put into danger. However, as I already mentioned, you can see those kinds of storylines on shows that dramatize the lives of first responders. Of course, we know they see some absolutely horrific scenes, and I’m sure some have strong PTSD from finding victims of all sorts of incidents whose lives they were unable to save, dead on arrival. And there’s mention of how this type of profession can affect their personal lives, but we don’t really get to see that as much as I would have liked. I think that’s probably where the strength is, not just following paramedics like an episode of Cops, but instead breaking it down to a more human core. What is it to be a paramedic? What is that life like? Not just the thrill of the chase or the fight to bring back the dead, but the actual toll it takes on a life. Those who make the choice to stay, why do they stay? Those who make the choice to leave, why do they leave? What is it like for the families of these first responders?
There’s a mention of when they come home, somebody asks them how their day was, and they just can’t explain it. So they just say fine, because they know their spouse won’t understand. So, do they find solace elsewhere? Is there a support group for first responders? Is there a high amount of alcoholism or something else that takes the place of therapy? It’s not that Into the Unknown is a bad documentary. It’s just an obvious documentary. It gave me, sadly, what I felt like I could have gotten while perusing cable television. It is what it claims to be, a documentary about first responders. But it doesn’t really go beyond the surface. It doesn’t really pull apart the psyche of first responders and give us an honest portrayal of the totality of their lives. However, it’s also not propaganda. So in that regard, I do appreciate it for being a realistic documentary that isn’t trying to paint a picture that these lives are full of saving kittens from trees. But I’m not sure it strives to be memorable.
It does what it needs to do in order to be considered a documentary on the subject matter it is tackling, but it is not so definitive that someone can’t come along after it and make another documentary about paramedics, first responders, firefighters or emergency medical technicians. It didn’t feel like it became the definitive breakdown of who these people are, both in and out of the rigs. There are some interesting ideas and concepts brought up, like from 2 Black female EMTs who mention how their community perceives them. They are well received for being Black in a predominantly Black community, and they can tell when they show up that the response they get is genuinely a more open response when they’re there to save lives. But they also face continued misogyny and this idea that women can’t be as good as men in their jobs, and that men think these little ladies won’t be able to carry them on a stretcher. I’m sure most of these men who have that same level of concern would probably be knocked out by Ronda Rousey in an instant. Masculine bravado is always misplaced and overcompensating.
So there are some thoughts, but I wish we could needle at them a little bit more. I really want to pull at the threads here and unravel what is a basic documentary to turn it into something more. I don’t want to just say, watch this documentary about first responders. It was good because it was exactly as advertised. I want to enthusiastically recommend a documentary that does something different, that took a step back, saw the big picture and figured out how to uniquely convey to the audience the entirety of what it means to make this life choice.
I did not get audio description with this, and I suppose it might have saved me from some graphic car crash footage or something, but for the most part, there are a lot of interviews with the various first responders, so it was a fairly easy documentary to follow. It just lacked visual context. But given the fact that the visual context here could be horrifying, I’m not entirely sure I missed it. There’s something, for this particular documentary, about the ambiguity of not knowing whether or not we are showing tragedy upon tragedy. And ultimately, that’s not what I was looking for anyway. I wanted a documentary that was unafraid to question what it is to be a first responder, what it takes, why people are drawn to it, why people stay, and what kind of effects it has broadly, even after clocking out for the day.
There are lingering questions that I felt went unanswered. And given the fact that these people spend so much time trying to save our lives, I feel like the true reverence here is in pointing out how much they give up, instead of what feels like the cinematic equivalent of a ride-along. Into the Unknown is fine. It should be better. But it treats those it intends to honor with respect. It just doesn’t do much more than that.
Fresh: 8.0/10