Kicking off the Small Screen Diaries, I’m in the middle of breaking the formula slightly. I did swerve, and it’s important to bring that up. I mostly focused on HBO Max shows, but I did include an extra show in here that is not on HBO Max, and I could have pretended like I didn’t watch it. But there was also something really interesting about it, so I had to include it. Anyway, without further ado, and spoiler warning, here are the rankings.
Coming in first place is War, season 1, episode 8, the season, probably series, finale of the Dominic West and Sienna Miller-led divorce drama, which I’m sure had people with mixed feelings over the ending, depending on who you wanted to see rise to the top. But I’m not really sure that was the point. It’s more of a dissection of what divorce proceedings can do to people, and how messy marriages can be, especially when you start throwing high amounts of wealth into them. But the show was excellent. Dominic West and Sienna Miller should get Emmy nominations for their work, and Archie Renaux also did really lovely work here as Johnny, who was perpetually stuck between law firms. The audio description by ZOO Digital, narrated by Xanthe Paige, was great throughout, tracking how everyone’s reactions to things, as the manipulation kept increasing, reflected the intended impact.
In second place, The Comeback, season 3, episode 5, with audio description from 3Play Media, written by Kathlyn Finn and narrated by Tanzi Alexander. It’s nice to have far improved audio description for The Comeback, and Lisa Kudrow really is great on the show. I wish people would use this show as a launching pad for her to do other things, and we didn’t have to keep waiting for someone to revive The Comeback every decade or so just so we could have some great Lisa Kudrow performances. In this episode, she’s still dealing with the fallout of finding out who her writers are and how disinterested they are in the production, and trying to curve things back around so that there are actual jokes written by humans in her show. It all ends with these celebration candles that she bought for everyone, and kind of a cool fade to black as she has to give away the cameraman’s candle because she didn’t get enough for everyone. So she’s kind of talking to the cameraman, which is the audience, about how she didn’t have a candle for them, which is also kind of for us.
Third place goes to Rick and Morty, season 9, episode 10, the season finale, with audio description. Some really lovely audio description here, as always, in an episode that sees Rick and Morty hopping through various dimensions, as whenever a pair of Ricks and Mortys die, the other ones come in and basically do an estate sale and take all their belongings. Which makes Morty aware that there are some worlds in which his whole family but him is still alive, and he wonders what that looks like. So he goes off on an adventure and finds a family that seems really caring and loving and accepting of Morty, but is that really what he needs? Or does he like a little bit of chaos in his life? This episode was great.
In 4th place, Youth, season 1, episode 4, with audio description. I kind of liked Michael. He wasn’t perfect, but I thought that’s what made him interesting as a potential love interest for Alex. But I guess we’re moving on from that pretty quickly, and she’s going back to her son, who, for reasons unbeknownst to the audience, will not stop scratching his balls throughout the course of this episode. And it was supposed to be funnier that she says he can keep calling Michael, since Michael was offering him advice, but it’s also kind of nonsensical. This is a mostly smart series. It just took a swing and a miss in the same episode.
In 5th place, President Curtis, season 1, episode 3, with audio description. It was fine. I thought the first 2 episodes were funnier. This one does have Gun Baby, though, which was an interesting choice of hilarity, and some horror movie references that were pretty funny.
And that brings me to last place, which is the show I wanted to talk about, because I don’t know what happened or what bamboozlement has befallen the blind community. But I’ll say, I just watched Celebrity Weakest Link on Disney+, a show which is in its 2nd season and is among the myriad of Fox programming I’ve been watching on Disney+ or Hulu this whole time. And I’m used to never hearing audio description, and for some reason, they passed through the audio description. Now, of course, it makes me want to check out more Fox shows when I have time. But I don’t know if Fox finally figured out how to pass through audio description to Disney+ and Hulu all of a sudden. It’s worth mentioning. Unfortunately, it’s not great audio description, but that doesn’t mean that the other Fox shows don’t have great audio description. So perhaps the pass-through problem has been fixed. I didn’t have the time to jump in and check to see if that was actually the case. But if so, it means I don’t have to keep waiting for series to port to Netflix before I can hear them with audio description. Color me intrigued. Also, definitely a ’90s throwback episode. I loved seeing all of the people they brought back, even if some of my favorites went out a little too early.
And that leaves me to the audio description rankings. I gotta say that since I can’t rank it anymore after this, even though I could say the same thing about War, I am really impressed with the audio description that Rick and Morty has. So I will tip my hat to the season finale of Rick and Morty as the winner of the day, and the loser is still Celebrity Weakest Link, but this time at least it has audio description. It’s just not good audio description. It’s really hard to describe that show in a meaningful capacity, but this is still not the way to do it. With these game shows, I realize there isn’t a ton of potential for effusive audio description, but you have to think about it from the perspective of the audience watching. What is it that they’re missing out on? And what could you fill in? What is the actual missing experience here? For example, as they go around and vote each time, would it be helpful for us to hear the name of who’s about to vote, quickly in there before they vote? Or are we expected to constantly memorize everyone’s voices? Because celebrity seems to be a spectrum now, and while I knew everyone except the Beverly Hills, 90210 star who was on here, that is not the case with every other episode. Especially when you’re familiar with people not for their speaking but for other things. Like when they bring Olympic athletes on, I don’t think people recognize their voices immediately. So it’s about using the right kind of audio description now, but we’re past the barrier, at least, of passing it through.