Ali G: Who Is I?

As someone who consumes a massive amount of pop culture, yes, I know who Ali G is, and I remember Da Ali G Show. However, I never actually watched the show, or much of anything involving Sacha Baron Cohen’s original creation, aside from perhaps some random clips on YouTube. I have, however, had the mostly pleasurable experience of enjoying his later attempts at doing virtually the same thing with characters like Borat, Brüno, and The Dictator. Cohen is someone who obviously prides himself on being able to disappear behind a ridiculous accent, an elaborate costume, and some form of hair and makeup that allows him to go unrecognized. Something that has to become increasingly difficult as his career progresses, considering he’s an Oscar-nominated actor who has appeared in numerous films and television shows, some of which have done quite well at the box office. Ali G: Who Is I? is a frustrating film because I’m not entirely sure why it even exists. Cohen is going back to square one, reviving a character who has been around long enough that most people should be familiar with him by now. Even if you never watched the original show, you’ve probably encountered a clip, a catchphrase, or one of his ridiculous interviews. Certainly, the success of Borat introduced an entirely new audience to Cohen’s work, likely inspiring people to go back and discover Ali G. Yet somehow, Cohen believes he can dust off this character, take another swing, and still find enough buffoons to bamboozle.

There is an actual plot to this film. God knows why. It involves Ali G getting his girlfriend pregnant and subsequently believing that HBO wants a third season of Da Ali G Show. So, he heads off to America to make that third season, hoping to establish some financial security before becoming a father. There are a whole bunch of other unnecessary things happening in a film that is supposed to be mostly satire, with Cohen showing up in character to provoke reactions and expose the absurdity of the people around him. Instead, there’s far too much plot involving actors who are in on the joke, rather than unsuspecting participants who have no idea what they’re getting themselves into. Borat, for example, had a relatively limited fictional narrative, with the character arriving in America as a citizen of Kazakhstan to bridge cultural gaps and explore American society. Very nice. The simplicity of that premise allowed the encounters themselves to drive the comedy. With Ali G, the character is obviously rooted in British comedy, so the satire arguably hits closer to home for audiences in the United Kingdom. Which makes it even stranger that Cohen has decided to bring him to America to wander around poking fun at politics, cancel culture, DEI, cultural appropriation, and perhaps even the backlash Cohen himself has received for creating a character like this. It’s difficult to determine who or what the actual target is, or what Cohen believes he’s proving. For a film built around exposing absurdity, it feels remarkably confused about its own intentions.

Just like his previous efforts, though, Cohen always manages to land at least one good zinger, and this time he convinces an American politician to participate in a scheme to kidnap the actress playing Ali G’s pregnant girlfriend before she can give birth on American soil, supposedly preventing the creation of an anchor baby. The politician has subsequently disputed his portrayal in the film and threatened legal action against Cohen, but regardless of how we got here, we still got here. It’s pretty damning that someone could be convinced to participate in something like this in the first place. The devil made me do it is not an effective defense, and just because this particular devil happens to be Sacha Baron Cohen dressed as Ali G doesn’t excuse the behavior. However, just because Cohen has gotten away with this kind of comedy before doesn’t necessarily explain why we’re still doing it in 2026. I know there are people who believe comedy is dead, and that the solution is to resurrect things we laughed at decades ago as evidence that comedy is supposed to be edgy and timeless simultaneously. But sometimes comedy belongs to the period in which it was created. Either those jokes retain their relevance, or society changes, and we learn something about why they may not work anymore.

Look at the Jackass crew, for example. The biggest thing working against that franchise is that everyone involved keeps getting older. Their comedy is fairly basic, consisting of increasingly idiotic things that put themselves in danger. It’s essentially a modern variation of slipping on a banana peel. Is that inherently and eternally funny, or does the joke eventually get old? Given how many times the Jackass crew has returned to the same well, an argument could be made that eventually even the banana peel loses its effectiveness. That doesn’t mean somebody else can’t come along and find a new way to make similar comedy work. Impractical Jokers has built an entire franchise around a comparable premise. But then there are other things we simply accept as products of their time, recognizing that we’ve moved beyond them. Song of the South was once a significant part of Disney’s history. Splash Mountain was originally themed around Br’er Rabbit, and the song Zip-a-Dee-Doo-Dah became practically synonymous with Disney itself. But as time progressed, we started having more meaningful conversations about the representation within Song of the South, the origins of those stories, and what it means to have characters like Br’er Rabbit associated with something like the tar baby storyline. Consequently, Song of the South has essentially vanished from Disney’s catalog, and Splash Mountain has given way to an attraction themed around The Princess and the Frog.

I’m old enough to have seen Song of the South theatrically when I was a kid, and to have read the Uncle Remus stories. But I’m also old enough to remember learning in elementary school that Christopher Columbus discovered America, only to get to high school and discover that Christopher Columbus did not, in fact, discover America. Knowledge is power, and the ability to listen to others, empathize with different points of view, and reevaluate what we’ve previously accepted doesn’t negate the past. It allows us to grow and enrich ourselves for the future. That’s why Cohen’s decision to revisit Ali G feels regressive, particularly when he overcomplicates the film by creating a narrative in which Ali G is essentially his own antagonist, facing off against a professor who recognizes that his entire persona is practically screaming cultural appropriation. There’s an opportunity here for Cohen to examine the very foundation of his creation, but he seems more interested in defending the character’s right to exist than seriously considering the criticism surrounding him. That’s not to say I never laughed. Cohen still gets some terrific reactions from unsuspecting people, but there aren’t nearly enough of them. Even early in the film, when he’s explaining who Ali G is and why we should care, he incorporates archival interview footage from the original show. Those sit-down interviews, and the ridiculous things people were willing to say to this character, should have been the bulk of the movie. Instead, we have a fake character with a fake pregnant girlfriend traveling to America to fight a fake villain, distracting from what could have been a fascinating examination of how the current American political system reacts to someone like Ali G.

For a moment, I wondered whether Ali G: Who Is I? might actually be Cohen’s attempt at an apology, or at least an introspective examination of his most famous creations. Something that would allow him to inhabit the character while simultaneously dissecting what it means for that character to exist, without automatically dismissing everyone who has ever found him offensive. There’s an interesting comparison to be made with Robert Downey Jr.‘s character in Tropic Thunder. Blackface is never okay, but the entire point of that character is to satirize an actor who becomes so obsessed with method acting and immersing himself in a role that he completely loses perspective. The absurdity of the performance is the criticism. It’s not simply asking audiences to laugh at a white actor playing a Black character, but at the extraordinary lengths an actor will go to in pursuit of some supposedly authentic artistic experience. The film holds a mirror up to the excesses of Hollywood, and the joke is largely at the expense of the person who believes his behavior is justified. Cohen seems hesitant to turn that same mirror on himself, perhaps because doing so would mean acknowledging that there might be some validity to the criticism of Ali G. That his creation was offensive to some people, that those objections weren’t necessarily unreasonable, and that the very stereotypes that helped launch his career might deserve reconsideration. It doesn’t mean he has to apologize for everything he’s ever done, but it would require a degree of introspection that this film seems unwilling to provide.

Ultimately, when you look at Ali G, Borat, Brüno, and The Dictator, they all have something in common. The joke is frequently at somebody else’s expense. Cohen creates outrageous characters built around exaggerated cultural stereotypes, then places them in situations where their ridiculous behavior exposes the ignorance, prejudice, or hypocrisy of the people around them. Sometimes that works brilliantly. Sometimes the character becomes more distracting than the point he’s trying to make. And sometimes you have to wonder whether the joke is actually saying anything meaningful at all. I don’t think Ali G: Who Is I? is a particularly effective example of comedy in 2026, and I can’t imagine Amazon has much confidence in the film’s commercial potential, considering it’s being released directly to streaming rather than receiving a traditional theatrical rollout. It feels less like a triumphant comeback and more like an obligation. A character being revived because somebody believes there’s still some value left in the brand, rather than because there’s a compelling reason to bring him back.

What makes this even more frustrating is that there are contemporary comedies that are considerably more offensive, and often far less interested in having a meaningful conversation. I’ve reviewed films that approach controversial subjects with such a staggering lack of self-awareness that the intended satire gets buried beneath the filmmakers’ own prejudices. Films that seem designed specifically to push harmful agendas, where the people responsible don’t particularly care who they offend and may even relish the fact that they’ve offended someone. Cohen, at the very least, has generally demonstrated an interest in exposing the ridiculousness of prejudice rather than simply celebrating it. That’s an important distinction, and one I’m willing to acknowledge even when I don’t think his comedy is particularly successful. But good intentions don’t automatically make something funny, and the fact that somebody else is making something more offensive doesn’t mean Cohen should be immune from criticism. There’s a difference between challenging an audience and simply recycling the same provocation, hoping it still produces the same reaction. At some point, you have to ask whether the comedian has anything new to say.

Sacha Baron Cohen wants to know who he is. He’s a talented actor, an occasionally brilliant comedian, and a man who desperately needs to grow up and take ownership of his creations. That means acknowledging that his comedy can potentially be damaging, rather than treating every criticism as proof that audiences have become too sensitive to appreciate the joke. I don’t believe comedy is dead, and I certainly don’t believe that being offensive automatically disqualifies something from being funny. But comedy has to evolve, just as the people creating it should evolve. Bringing back Ali G without finding anything particularly insightful to say about the character, the world around him, or the man responsible for creating him feels like a wasted opportunity. Cohen has spent decades convincing people that he’s somebody else. Maybe it’s time he figured out who he actually is. Comedy isn’t dead. This just isn’t comedy.

Rotten: 3.5/10

Leave a Reply