Kicking off the Small Screen Diaries for the day is something that has very little to do with the small screen and more to do with a hilarious moment of embarrassment in my life. When my review of You Can See Everything hit Rotten Tomatoes, the world found it and came to remind me that they also saw everything, including the fact that I incorrectly identified Lance Oppenheim as Joshua Oppenheimer. Now, there is an actual documentary filmmaker named Joshua Oppenheimer, who also directed The End. Lance Oppenheim just made Primetime, and perhaps if I had seen Primetime, his name would have been on my brain. Instead, I kept putting Joshua because, well, I’m an idiot. But I’ve decided to leave the glaring error in place, especially since people have already pointed it out in the comments. My review of You Can See Everything is now my scarlet letter. There’s something ironic about altering a review of a film that’s about radical transparency, isn’t there? Shouldn’t I be radically transparent about the fact that I did, in fact, fuck up? I’m human, not a robot. Contrary to popular belief, I am not artificial.
First place goes to Dark Matter, Season 2, Episode 4, on Apple TV with audio description by Pixel Logic. What I really liked about this episode was how it continued exploring the concept of varying versions of people from different worlds colliding in increasingly interesting ways. Even after a couple has fought so hard to stay together, they can still have marital problems they haven’t addressed, which leads to a somewhat heartbreaking ending. I also really loved Ryan in this episode. The hilarity of having two versions of him running around was smart, and then there’s the Amanda they’re buying in the world they’ve landed in. I’m very intrigued by what’s going on there. This is complicated storytelling designed for audiences willing to follow along and pay attention. It’s not something you can casually put on in the background. Excellent performances from Joel Edgerton, Jimmi Simpson, and Jennifer Connelly.
In second place is Breaking Bad, Season 5, Episode 1, on Netflix with audio description from Descriptive Video Works, narrated by Diane Newman. Yes, I’ve finally made it to Season 5. My rewatch is getting closer to being complete, and yes, I did put Dark Matter over Breaking Bad. There’s something about this fifth-season introduction and some of the choices being made that feels like a deviation from the strong four-season arc they’ve been building. It almost feels like hitting a reset button. I’d call this a transitional moment, a little like Dexter having to pick up the pieces after the Trinity Killer season. I’m not 100% sure this final stretch will be as strong as the first four seasons, but we’ll see. The performances are still excellent, and the entire sequence involving the magnet is brilliant. I absolutely saw it coming that Walt would push things to the limit. That haunting ending, with the words “I forgive you,” really solidifies just how far this cancer-stricken chemistry teacher has come over four full seasons. It’s also heartbreaking to revisit the series following the recent loss of RJ Mitte, who played Walter White Jr.
Third place goes to Youth on HBO Max with audio description narrated by Mari Morrison. I didn’t catch the company because my screen reader decided to talk over the credits. This series is holding up really well, and I’m enjoying Youth far more than I enjoyed Bad Sisters from the same creator. This is definitely one to watch, especially when awards season rolls around, because I think it’ll be competing in at least the Best Actress category. Her son is now home and doesn’t want to return to college, but she doesn’t understand why. When they eventually go back to the college, she gets a glimpse of why he might be reluctant to return, realizing there’s more to the story than he’s telling her. We don’t uncover that larger mystery in the second episode just yet, but I’m definitely interested in seeing where this goes.
In fourth place is the always lovely Have I Got News for You, which does not have audio description on HBO Max. A possible contender for worst audio description of the day, but only because there isn’t any, and there probably never will be. Regardless, it’s always a welcome injection of humor into my day.
In fifth place is Avatar: Seven Havens, Season 1, Episode 2, on Paramount+ with audio description from International Digital Center. I liked this second episode, which showed the twin sisters meeting for the first time and realizing they’re both Avatars, without quite making the connection that they’ve apparently been Parent Trapped at some point and separated. Even though they have memories of playing together when they were younger. They’re already kids, so I guess they were even younger kids. I don’t know how you have that many memory lapses when you’re so young, but whatever. The two eventually have to team up and use their powers to fight an incredibly destructive storm threatening their land. They’re definitely on their way to becoming the Avatars, and I’m interested in seeing how this relationship develops.
In sixth place is Elsbeth, Season 4, Episode 1, on Paramount+ with audio description by the Media Access Group. This season premiere was fine. In terms of Elsbeth episodes, the mystery, the special guest, and the way the story unfolds, they’ve done better. I love this show, and I’m a big fan of Carrie Preston, but this was not my favorite episode and felt a little weak out of the gate, especially considering everything they left hanging at the end of Season 3 and where the characters are now. I still think Elsbeth needs a Moriarty. She needs someone like what they were trying to do with Michael Emerson, but someone who isn’t getting away with things because they have power or influence. They’re getting away with things because they’re genuinely intelligent. She needs an adversary who can challenge her intellectually instead of these one-off mysteries where she’s constantly leaping to giant conclusions and, surprisingly, always being right. Give her someone who can actually keep up with her.
Seventh place goes to The Gentlemen on Netflix with audio description. They’re currently shooting Season 3, so fans should hopefully get a pretty quick turnaround. I think the second season has been okay, but I’m very intrigued by the massive injection of new cast members planned for the third season, which they’re apparently also shooting in Morocco. That’s quite a change of location, and I’m curious to see how this season ends and what they’re setting up that would allow for such a significant influx of new characters. I’m also hoping that doesn’t mean too many existing cast members are leaving, because Ray Winstone is excellent here, and a move to Morocco doesn’t necessarily bode well for his character sticking around. The audio description is solid. I didn’t have any problems with it. But The Gentlemen itself is just okay. It needs a little more of that Guy Ritchie vibe than it’s currently delivering. The Gentlemen needs to go watch a few episodes of Young Sherlock and then come back.
In eighth place is Tomb Raider King, Season 1, Episode 10, on Crunchyroll with audio description from Global 3. I think they may have changed writers here because I heard a name in the credits that I don’t remember hearing before. I believe Melvina Babu had been writing the audio description, and at some point, there may have been a transition to somebody new. I didn’t notice any significant drop in quality, though, and the episode still feels very much like every other episode. This series plays almost like a video game, with the relics functioning as power-ups or special abilities you acquire as you progress. You’re trying to keep your companions alive because they also have abilities and assets that can help you along the way. It’s still very likely a synthetic voice narrating the audio description, although I recently encountered another production from Global 3 that actually credited a human narrator. So it’s not like this company exclusively works with synthetic voices. They may just not be crediting the narrators on certain projects. Either way, the description here remains consistent with what I’ve come to expect.
In last place is Outlander: Blood of My Blood, Season 2, Episode 1, on Starz without audio description. Which is exactly why it’s in dead last. This is an incredibly difficult show to struggle through without accessibility, even though I’m a fan of the Outlander franchise and spiritually do enjoy this series. The music, however, is absolutely gorgeous. If I were ranking shows purely on their scores, Outlander: Blood of My Blood would win every single time. It would probably beat every other show on television. I don’t think there’s a series more deserving of an Emmy for its score. At least, I haven’t heard one yet. I could listen to this music all day long, which is probably heightened by the fact that I have no idea what’s happening in half the plot. However, they did that thing again where only one character goes back to the future, leaving everyone else in the past, separated once again by time. And I’m sitting here thinking, haven’t we already done this shit in Outlander? Can we just not? I kind of wish we’d gone in a different direction, but I’ll still try to pay attention to the season. I just wish Starz actually knew blind people existed. It’s amazing how much they apparently don’t.
That brings us to the audio description winner and loser of the day. The obvious loser is Outlander: Blood of My Blood, because it’s a narrative series without audio description, and Starz has been around for roughly 30 years. They know better. They should be producing audio description for their original programming, and I don’t understand how we’ve allowed them to slide through society for this long without making accessibility a priority. It’s baffling that practically all of their competition is producing audio description while Starz stubbornly sits there with its head in the sand, pretending blind audiences don’t exist. As for the winner, you can call me a basic bitch, but I’m sticking with Breaking Bad. There are so many beautifully described moments, from Walt cleaning up his mess to make sure he isn’t discovered, to everything involving the magnet, to even the smaller scenes like Walt’s interactions with Saul. The description captures the physical action, the tension, and the character dynamics without losing the momentum of the episode. It’s such a well-described hour of television that I couldn’t possibly pick anything else. Breaking Bad takes the audio description crown today, and Starz can go sit in the corner and think about what it’s done.