Kicking off today’s Small Screen Diaries is a brand new show, something that I heard through the grapevine from critics was going to be excellent, and that is the new HBO Max drama War, starring Dominic West and Sienna Miller. This definitely piqued my interest, although I think the title may be a little soft and not necessarily descriptive of what the show is actually about. We’ll see with later episodes if they end up justifying the title. Sort of like how Succession told you exactly what that show was about, War seems to perhaps go a little bit overboard, as this is basically a divorce drama, at least at this point. Granted, the parties involved are wealthy and powerful, but I suppose when you’re HBO and you’ve already made a show called Divorce, there’s not really much more you can do. Find an adjective, maybe? Separation? I don’t know. But I did really like the show. It’s technically British, so it has an appropriately British audio description track to match.
I followed that up with Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story, season one, episode two, on Netflix. While this is not entirely my thing, I think creatively it is stronger than the previous seasons so far, at least. The second episode deals a lot with Lizzie reaching a breaking point with her parents, but not that breaking point. Just reaching the point where she’s done with them because her stepmother is a bitch and her father does not care. Plus, her relationship with her maid is continuing to blossom. There is still a fair amount of gore in the episode, as they relive the story about the woman who likes to bathe in blood, and then there’s also a lot of vomiting and diarrhea in this episode. But I think if you have watched any of the previous Monster seasons, you know what you’re in for. This is not a pleasant experience.
A slightly more pleasant experience was the season premiere of South Park, which I’m finally catching up to. I had heard basically what it was about, which is why I kind of delayed, plus since they’re doing every other week, I can space this out as much as I want. But the season premiere of South Park does have audio description by now, certainly on Paramount+, and it is Trey Parker and Matt Stone largely going after e-bikes. Yes, there was a lot of noise about them renaming the series South America, and they go full-on with that, completely changing the opening theme song to represent the new title. But it’s basically just about the new e-bike craze and typical South Park humor.
I did season one, episode two of Last Scene on Apple TV+, and this was much better than the first episode. I also chose to go about watching it in a different way. Instead of trying to watch it through my TV, where I didn’t feel like the sound was balanced very well, I used headphones, like I do for a lot of shows, which solved that problem. When you have headphones designed to give you a special surround sound experience, they handled this way better than my TV did. However, I should not have wildly different experiences depending on how I’m watching something, because most of these shows I end up watching both through headphones and through my TV. Last Scene’s mix is noticeably different between the two. And the second episode is crazy good and ends on a big cliffhanger, so I am far more engaged in the series than I was before. The first episode did a lot of setup, while the second episode sold me on sticking around for even more. The audio description is decent in terms of providing context, especially in the scenes where it’s really ramping up the danger.
I got caught up on The Traitors: New Blood, and we’re basically just waiting to see the results of the funeral and all of the stuff that went down during the challenge. The network version of The Traitors definitely keeps ending in weird places that make people wait an entire week for the next episode to drop. I wonder how the ratings are playing for this on NBC versus how it plays on Peacock. But there’s human audio description here, and that’s something to be celebrated because the audio description is way better than it was during the first couple seasons of The Traitors. They made the switch to human audio description in season four and haven’t looked back since, and I’m incredibly appreciative of that.
I did watch one show without audio description today, Celebrity Weakest Link on Disney+. I’m sure it airs with audio description, and this is just Fox being incapable of porting it over to Disney+ in time. So I watched Jane Lynch have a bunch of people she had worked with on the show, and one of the people I was least familiar with ended up winning. So there’s that.
Finally, at the end, I caught up on another episode of The Rookie, which sent its cast into various different places. It’s amazing how large this ensemble is and how much they’re able to maintain, even when you think about recurring characters like Dash, who keep coming into the show. He’s not a cop. He’s not a rookie. He’s just part of the experience, and he’s been in a handful of episodes already. This episode largely centers around Dash and Nolan eventually rescuing him. The B-plot either has Wesley and his friend Sean giving their last middle finger on the way out the door, or it centers around Juarez and her special assignment with Missing Persons, which goes fairly predictably.
So, of these shows, I again find myself in the conundrum where I don’t think anything actually had bad audio description. However, there was one show that did not have audio description, and that was Celebrity Weakest Link, which ends up being the default loser of the day. But which one of these is the winner? Which one stood out as having the actual best audio description? By a pretty close margin, I think Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story probably has the most stuff to describe and has to deal with quite a lot that some of these other programs don’t, because they’re presented pretty much as-is. So I’ll give it to Monster.